Matthew Mann
January 31, 2008 | Compliance | Matthew Mann

Why Costco is Important

Reading this week’s Costco v. Hoen decision by the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals is enough to make any non-lawyer’s eyes glaze over. Much of the legal analysis is about just that, what line of analysis should be applied when making the decision as to whether the state of Washington’s rights protected by the 21st Amendment to regulate alcohol is trumped by the antitrust provisions of the Sherman Antitrust Act. Important stuff, but not interesting reading for most people. The ultimate result turned on the Circuit Court’s rejecting the District Court’s analytical framework, thereby reaching the opposite conclusion. All of the esoterica about “post and hold” and “central warehousing” issues are important to industry professionals but the layperson probably doesn’t much care about such things. So why is this decision important? Costco is important because the Circuit Court made a point of applying an analytical framework that would shore up the current three-tier system at a time when it has been slowly chipped away by free trade advocates, of which I am one, I should say. This line of analytical reasoning will no doubt be used by future courts looking to uphold the current system. I frequently speak of legal precedent and it’s importance in this blog and this case sets a huge precedent by reversing a trend towards modernizing the three-tier system. There are merits to the three-tier system and I’m not one looking to entirely junk it in favor of a free-for-all system. But the system needs to catch up to modern technology and the way business is done in the 21st century. This decision is one that will hinder that prospect for some time.


cialis's Gravatar
@ Nov 6, 2014 at 9:10 AM
Every weekend i used to go to see this site, because i want enjoyment, for the reason that this this web page conations really fastidious funny data too.

productos bancarios's Gravatar
productos bancarios
@ May 5, 2016 at 4:37 PM
Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to say that I've really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon!

productos bancarios

Add A Blog Comment
E-Mail me when someone comments on this post
Leave this field blank:

Stay Connected

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Stay informed of upcoming events and direct sales news.


Learn More About WineDirect's End-to-End Solutions

Our full suite of services will help you sell more wine DTC.

Learn More

© Copyright 2017 WineDirect . All Rights Reserved.